Why is Shinnecock Hills considered a difficult course for the U.S. Open?

Shinnecock Hills is known for its demanding layout, which has led to high winning scores and player criticism, such as Zach Johnson's comments about the course being "beyond the edge" of fairness during the 2018 U.S. Open.

What is Shinnecock Hills' status with the USGA for future championships?

While not an official "anchor site," Shinnecock Hills is considered a long-term fixture for the U.S. Open. The USGA plans for it to host both the women's and men's U.S. Opens in consecutive weeks in 2036, indicating a strong commitment to the venue.

MajorsBy the GolfOdds Editorial TeamJul 4, 2026, 5:00 PM ET

Shinnecock Hills Set for Another Grueling U.S. Open Test

Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, a historic U.S. Open venue, is poised to challenge the world's top golfers once more, known for its demanding layout that has drawn player criticism in the past.

Shinnecock Hills Golf Club is preparing to host the U.S. Open for the sixth time, solidifying its place in the championship's rotation. The Southampton, N.Y., course has a reputation for presenting a formidable challenge, as evidenced by the 2018 U.S. Open where Brooks Koepka claimed victory with a final score of one-over par. That event underscored the demanding nature of Shinnecock, pushing even elite players to their limits.

The course's difficulty was a significant topic of discussion during the 2018 tournament. Following his third round, Zach Johnson, currently priced at +7158 (Pinnacle) for the John Deere Classic, expressed strong criticism of the conditions. When asked if the course was on the edge of fairness versus playability, Johnson stated, "Ahh, no, we’re not on the edge. I thought we could be on the edge, but we’ve surpassed it. Yeah it’s pretty much gone, specifically the latter part of the day." His comments highlighted the extreme test the course presented, particularly as the rounds progressed.

A Recurring Championship Venue

Despite its challenging reputation, Shinnecock Hills holds a special place with the United States Golf Association (USGA). While not officially designated an "anchor site" like Pinehurst No. 2, Oakmont Country Club, or Pebble Beach Golf Links, the USGA views Shinnecock as a long-term fixture for its championships. USGA CEO Mike Whan indicated that the U.S. Open will return frequently, with the course already slated to host both the women's and men's U.S. Opens in consecutive weeks in 2036. This commitment reflects Shinnecock's historical significance as one of the five founding clubs of the USGA in 1895.

The demanding layout of Shinnecock Hills traditionally favors players with exceptional ball-striking ability and mental fortitude. Brooks Koepka's victory in 2018, finishing over par, exemplifies the type of grind required to succeed here. As the U.S. Open returns, players like Koepka, who is currently priced at +5500 (BetRivers) for The Open Championship, will be among those expected to contend, given their proven ability to navigate the most challenging major championship conditions.

Compare the odds

U.S. Open odds →John Deere Classic odds →The Open Championship odds →Brooks Koepka Zach Johnson JJ Spaun

FAQ

Why is Shinnecock Hills considered a difficult course for the U.S. Open?: Shinnecock Hills is known for its demanding layout, which has led to high winning scores and player criticism, such as Zach Johnson's comments about the course being "beyond the edge" of fairness during the 2018 U.S. Open.
What is Shinnecock Hills' status with the USGA for future championships?: While not an official "anchor site," Shinnecock Hills is considered a long-term fixture for the U.S. Open. The USGA plans for it to host both the women's and men's U.S. Opens in consecutive weeks in 2036, indicating a strong commitment to the venue.